The White House has established a $100 million program that endorses fast-track, boot camp IT training efforts and other four-year degree alternatives. But this plan is drawing criticism because of the underlying message it sends in the H-1B battle.
The federal program, called TechHire, will get its money from H-1B visa fees, and the major users of this visa are IT services firms that outsource jobs.
Southern California Edison, for instance, is in the final phase of cutting 500 IT jobs as it shifts work to two India-based offshore providers. Many of the IT workers at the utility have had to train their visa-holding replacements.
Another source of controversy will be the White House's assertion that there are 545,000 unfilled IT jobs. It has not explained how it arrived at this number, but the estimate will likely be used as a talking point by lawmakers seeking to raise the H-1B cap.
The government has been using H-1B fees all along to award training grants. But TechHire seems more focused, particularly on helping IT and coding training programs at community colleges and private boot camps.
President Barack Obama said in speech Monday in Washington that the program's goals are "to help employers link up and find and hire folks based on their actual skills and not just their resumes. It doesn't matter where you learned code, it just matters how good you are in writing code.
"If you can do the job, you should get the job," he said.
This sentiment was applauded by some of the groups that provide fast-track training. Dev Bootcamp, which has a 19-week curriculum that teaches the skills needed to work as a Web developer, believes it "validates the role" of accelerated training programs, said Hilary Wells, a spokeswoman for firm.
The $100 million will be made available through grants distributed by the Department of Labor to organizations, employers, training institutions and others that address the White House goals.
The announcement arrives at the same time lawmakers have been fighting over raising the H-1B visa cap.
"It is a profound irony that the White House is funding this initiative through the hiring of foreign guest workers," said Stephen Miller, a spokesman for U.S. Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala), who has been critical of legislation to increase the H-1B cap. "I imagine this will be of little comfort to the California Edison workers asked to train their H-1B replacements."
Making matters worse, said Miller, is the White House support for raising the H-1B cap, "meaning that countless more Americans who pursue IT careers will find themselves locked out of the profession to which they have devoted their professional lives."
Norm Matloff, a professor of computer science at the University of California-Davis who has long challenged the idea that there's a shortage of technical talent, said "the subtext of the White House announcement is to justify expanding the H-1B program."
Matloff said it's the "old 'Let's train Americans so that employers don't need to hire H-1Bs' argument, and that argument is demonstrably false," he said.
"Just look at all the cases, including the recent Southern California Edison incident, in which Americans are laid off and forced to train their foreign-worker replacements; Clearly, it's the foreign workers who need the training, not the Americans," said Matloff. "The fact is that employers don't want to hire Americans; they want cheap, immobile labor."
The estimate of 545,000 IT job openings was met with skepticism by Victor Janulaitis, the CEO of Janco Associates, which analyzes the tech labor market. He said the number of job openings is "nowhere near" that estimate, and may be closer to 60,000. By the White House estimate it would mean that nearly 17% of the IT labor market has unfilled jobs.
But a lot of the openings are for specific skills and experience, and not entry level jobs, said Janulaitis. Technologists with specialties in security, containerization, cloud-based apps and big data can find jobs. "The real issue is when entry-level positions will be available," he said.
David Foote, the CEO of Foote Partners, an IT labor analyst firm, said an accounting of the tech labor force comes down to how IT jobs are defined. The feds use a narrow definition, which puts the labor force at about 5 million IT jobs. His firm, however, estimates that there may be as many as 24 million IT jobs, and counts jobs outside an IT department, as technology is embedded in all lines of a business.
Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.