Menu
Menu
Nehalem tower servers: Dell, Fujitsu, HP

Nehalem tower servers: Dell, Fujitsu, HP

Three new servers combine huge performance gains with excellent management tools; choice comes down to expandability, price

Rank and file

At the end of my testing, it was very clear to me that Intel's new Xeons have opened a new door of server performance. Nehalem represents a landmark shift in processing power, and all three servers demonstrated this fact with their fantastic SPECjbb2005 and STREAM 5.8 performance numbers. Regardless of the task, it will run faster on a Nehalem-based server.

The uniformly excellent performance made it very difficult to rank the three servers. In the final analysis, the differences in scores came down to minor things like hardware expandability, power consumption, and price. All of these servers are impressive performers, and none of them lacks any substantial features. All of them are great for small to medium-sized businesses, and each one's remote management is top notch. If noise is a concern, then look to the Dell. If you need room for lots of hard drives, then the Fujitsu is the one. If cost is king, HP is your choice. You won't go wrong with any of them.

Dell PowerEdge T610

Dell has always had style on its side, and the PowerEdge T610 keeps the tradition going. This stand-alone tower, which can also serve as a 5U rack server, bundles power behind a pretty face. The chassis has plenty of room for growth for any small to medium-sized business, capable of 8TB of internal storage and 96GB of DDR3 RAM. Remote management chores are handled by iDRAC6 (Integrated Dell Remote Access Controller). A nifty front-panel mini-LCD does the trick for boot-time monitoring.

Nehalem tower servers by the features

Dell PowerEdge T610

Fujitsu Primergy TX300

HP ProLiant ML350

Installed CPUs / max CPUs

2/2

2/2

2/2

Type of CPU (as tested)

Intel Xeon X5550 2.26 GHz

Intel Xeon X5550 2.26 GHz

Intel Xeon X5550 2.26 GHz

Installed RAM / max RAM

24GB/96GB

24GB/144GB

24GB/196GB

RAM type/speed?

DDR3 Registered, 1333MHz

DDR3 Registered, 1333MHz

DDR3 Registered, 1333MHz

# of RAM sockets

12 DIMM slots

18 DIMM slots

18 DIMM slots

# of PCIe slots

5 PCIs slots

7 PCIe slots

6 PCIe slots/2 PCI-X optional

# of USB ports

8 USB ports

10 USB ports

6 USB ports

Drive bay options

8 SFF or LFF

20 SFF or 8 LFF

16 SFF or 8 LFF

Disk type options (SATA/SAS/SCSI)

SAS, SATA, SSD

SAS, SATA

SAS, SATA

Controller types

SAS controller

SAS controller

SAS controller

# and type of drives installed (as tested)

4 x 73GB 15K RPM SAS

3x 450 GB 15K RPM SAS HDD

3 x 146G 10K RPM SAS

Max storage available

8TB

8TB

8TB

Front Panel LCD?

Yes

Yes

No

# and type of Ethernet ports

2 port GbE

2 port GbE

2 port GbE

Integrated management

iDRAC6

iRMC

iLO2

Power supply options

570W/870W, redundant optional

800W hot-plug standard, redundant optional

460W/750W/1200W, redundant optional

Tool less case design?

Yes

Yes

Yes

Chassis type

Tower or 5U rack

Tower or 4U rack

Tower or 5U rack

Hot-swap fans?

No, redundant fan support

Yes

No, redundant fan support

Price as tested

$7,315

$9,316

$6,560

Warranty

3 Years

3 Years

3 Years

This 11th-generation PowerEdge came to me outfitted with its pair of Xeon X5550 CPUs stashed safely underneath massive tower heat sinks and a large front-to-back air baffle. Two 90mm fans (there's room for two more) are mounted in the back of the baffle, directing air flow across the processors, RAM, and the installed hard drives. These rear-mounted fans are responsible for all cooling in the system with the exception of the fan in the power supply. As with the HP ProLiant, none of the fans are hot-swappable.

My Dell server came equipped with eight external USB 2.0 ports (six rear, two front) and five PCIe slots, two more than the HP. The Dell lacks an internal USB port for bare-metal booting from USB, a feature found in both Fujitsu's Primergy and HP's ProLiant. The interior of the chassis is cleanly laid out with all cables routed neatly and tucked away.

Dell provides two power supply options for the T610: a 570-watt or an 870-watt unit. Either power supply can be installed as a single unit or in an optional redundant configuration. Noise levels when under load were very good -- quiet enough to be deployed in a small office. Regardless of configuration, I like that the power supplies are also tool-less and can be replaced in a matter of seconds by simply releasing the locking clip and pulling the unit out.

Power consumption for the PowerEdge T610 was best of the group. At idle (meaning booted up but not under load), the T610 drew 136.6 watts, 19.8 watts less than the HP and almost 90 watts better than the Fujitsu. At 100 percent CPU utilization, the Dell still had the edge. The T610 averaged 307 watts, 15 watts less than the HP and nearly 60 watts less than the Fujitsu.

A server is not much good if it can't store data. Dell has a variety of drive and controller combinations available. My test server came configured with four 2.50-inch 73GB 15K RPM SAS hard drives in RAID 5. Other available drive options are 2.5-inch and 3.5-inch SATA II hard drives and 2.5-inch SSD (solid-state drive). A PERC6/I controller handles drive interface duties, while an optional integrated PERC6/I RAID daughter card allows for RAID levels of 0, 1, 5, 6, and 10.

Network options are pretty cut and dried with all three servers. The T610 comes with two integrated Broadcom NetXtreme II 5709c Gigabit Ethernet ports. Both ports provide failover and load balancing capabilities. Optional Gigabit and 10 Gigabit PCIe interface cards are also available.

When it comes to managing the T610, Dell has some of the coolest tools available. The Integrated Dell Remote Access Controller 6 (iDRAC6) microprocessor handles the remote management chores. I tested iDRAC6 Express, which not only provides remote power-on and management capabilities, but also crashed system recovery, firmware and driver updates, and hardware inventory. The iDRAC6 Enterprise option adds advanced features such virtual media support. This allows admins to boot the server from a CD-ROM, ISO image, or USB memory stick located on a remote desktop.

When used in conjunction with Dell's Unified System Configurator and Lifecycle Controller, iDRAC6 lets admins remotely provision and deploy bare-metal servers without any local IT support. For example, on initial power-up, the T610 with iDRAC6 can be automatically discovered by Lifecycle Controller back at the network operations center. Then, a new operating system -- be it a predefined "golden image" or a custom configuration -- can be pushed to the server using hardware drivers already resident on the iDRAC6 controller. In short, you can do a full server installation from remote, regardless of the status of the operating system, saving time and money without the need for onsite technical support.

Bottom line: The PowerEdge T610 is a great small office server that performed at the same level as its Nehalem-based brethren. It was the quietest of the three servers even during heavy CPU usage, making it a great choice when the server will share space with office workers. It doesn't have as many available drive bays as the Fujitsu and HP servers, but it still manages the same overall maximum disk storage. Remote management is solid and power consumption was best of the group.

Next: Fujitsu Primergy TX300 S5

Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags HPserversDellFujitsunehalemreviews

Show Comments
Computerworld
ARN
Techworld
CMO