Satyam fraud has ramifications for outsourcers

Satyam fraud has ramifications for outsourcers

Satyam's customers and competitors should brace themselves for near-term disruptions across the outsourcing industry

3. Disruptions to customers of other outsourcing vendors

The disruption of outsourced services will not be limited to Satyam's customers: Current customers of other outsourcing vendors can also expect near-term impacts on their outsourced operations. Apart from the inevitable strains to these vendors' infrastructures as they accommodate business from Satyam, customers may see the most experienced and skilled personnel on their engagements reassigned to the transition of former Satyam accounts. In addition to vigilantly monitoring service-level agreements, existing customers may mitigate such disruptions by exercising their contractual protections regarding personnel experience requirements, skill sets and attrition rates.

4. Opportunities for multinational vendors

Apprehensions regarding the financial standards of "India Inc." might benefit multinational outsourcing vendors, which are positioned to proffer outsourced services from India free of negative perceptions regarding that country's financial controls. Following Satyam's announcement, Indian vendors have taken measures to dispel customer concerns, and, in the long term, the scandal may benefit India's outsourcing industry by accelerating the maturation of financial controls. However, in the immediate aftermath of the scandal, the likes of IBM, Accenture, Oracle and SAP appear well positioned to acquire work from Satyam as well as newer customer opportunities.

5. Re-evaluation of Sarbanes-Oxley compliance by outsourcing customers

The Satyam developments may raise concerns for public-company filers regarding their compliance with Sarbanes-Oxley Act provisions pertaining to outsourced operations. Under guidance from the SEC and the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), customers have generally relied upon SAS 70 reports prepared by the vendors' auditors in order to attest to the financial controls over the outsourced operations. The apparent failure of Satyam's internal controls may raise uncertainty regarding continued reliance on such reports, and with 10-K season approaching, outsourcing customers may seek further guidance from the SEC. It remains to be seen if these developments will, in the longer term, trigger a reassessment of the SAS 70 standard and reliance on same by the PCAOB and/or SEC.

6. The potentially misleading 'admission' letter may raise unwarranted concerns regarding the financial viability of offshore outsourcing

Apprehensions have been voiced regarding whether the Satyam scandal is a "one-off" or a precursor to future failures of outsourcing vendors. In his letter of resignation last week, Raju claimed that he inflated Satyam's earnings in order to conceal margins that were dramatically below industry norms. However, as many commentators have observed, there is reason to believe that this "admission" itself is misleading and that Satyam's cash shortfall will be traced not to any deficiencies in the company's revenue model, but rather to self-dealing. Accordingly, for all of the gratuitous disruptions it has caused to the outsourcing industry, it does not appear that the Satyam scandal will discredit the industry's financial viability.

Shaalu Mehra is a partner at law firm Perkins Coie LLP and chairman of the firm's outsourcing and India practices. He can be reached at

Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags outsourcingSatyam

More about Accenture AustraliaACTIBM AustraliaOraclePerkins CoieSAP AustraliaSASSatyam Computer ServicesSEC

Show Comments