Saturday | 30 August, 2008
CIO
How to Salvage Your Company's Deep Smarts
The deep smarts of organizations are walking out the door. Deep smarts are the contents in the heads of experts that enable them to make swift, wise decisions based on years of experience. The solution to losing deep smarts, in short, is to invest in their re-creation.
Dorothy Leonard 30 January, 2006 15:06:52

Related Features
  • +

    Process Trip 04 February, 2008 13:07:03

    Why Maritz Travel revamped key business processes — and how business and IT came together to make it work
    When Rich Phillips became COO OF Maritz Travel about two and-a-half years ago, he sat down and took a hard look at the big industry picture
  • +

    Doing Your Sums on . . . Build, Buy or Rent 05 November, 2007 13:32:30

    You’re trying to build a world-class IT team, but everyone’s going after the same talent pool. What mix works best? Should you grow your own, draft your players or barter your way to the line-up you want to field?
    CIOs should never forget that while new technologies have a maturity cycle, the maturity cycle for human beings in IT is even longer
Related Stories
  • +

    Bill Gates: A New Approach to Capitalism in the 21st Century 28 January, 2008 07:12:19

    Transcript of Gates speech, and a Q&A at World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland
    As you all may know, in July I'll make a big career change. I'm not worried; I believe I'm still marketable. I'm a self-starter, I'm proficient in Microsoft Office. I guess that's it. Also I'm learning how to give money away.
Additional Resources
Executive Guides
Whitepapers

Newsletter Subscription

Sign up for our CIO newsletters!
Weekly coverage of the issues that impact corporate and government information
RSS Feeds

The approaching exodus of retiring baby boomers will severely erode the knowledge base of many companies. Fortunately, there are ways to re-create this crucial expertise.

The deep smarts of organizations are walking out the door. Deep smarts are the contents in the heads of experts that enable them to make swift, wise decisions based on years of experience. A number of trends threaten to converge into a perfect storm of knowledge loss, especially in the technical- and science-based occupations. While the percentage of highly skilled workers made up of foreign-born scientists and engineers has steadily increased in the past two decades, their native countries now want them back.

And then there is the approaching mass exodus of retirees. In many industries, these employees have knowledge that is essential to organizational success. But financially strapped companies are doing increasingly less on-the-job training, which is essential for transferring these deep smarts to the next generation. In Deep Smarts: How to Cultivate and Transfer Enduring Business Wisdom, Walter Swap and I argue that leaders need to identify, nurture and transfer the know-how comprising the engine of their organizations. Every organization has a few key members whose departure would devastate operations. Of course, not all retirees have a knowledge treasure buried in their craniums. And even those who do are subject to the same social and psychological biases as the general population, biases that can sometimes blind our judgement.

But people with deep smarts can be indispensable. Why? Because their particular brand of expertise is based on long, hard-won experience. They are the go-to people known for their swift, seemingly intuitive judgments. Such experts differ from their less experienced colleagues in having the ability to view a problem at a system level and yet dive into the details when necessary-and identify a familiar pattern.

Consider the example of a rocket scientist who saved the day because of his deep smarts. In the early 1980s, his company was competing with another for a US government contract to produce tactical missiles, worth billions of dollars over the next 30 to 40 years. Each competitor tested six working prototypes; none was satisfactory. The scientist, who was not an official member of the project team, called the primary participants to a meeting. He proceeded to awe the assembly by proposing detailed changes that he had worked out by himself during just one week of concentrated effort. Without notes, for several hours, he walked them through the redesign-from the weapon point to its aft-explaining all the software, wiring and hardware changes that would be required to win the competition. His changes were supported and the company won the contract.

It was rocket science, but the scientist didn't get deep smarts from his formal education alone. His kind of expertise accrued over 20 years of working on all different components of the missiles. In this example, the knowledge that could be lost was not only particular to the industry but also proprietary to the company. When such individuals retire or leave, the company suffers a blow from which it may take years to recover.

Re-creating Deep Smarts

Not all deep smarts are this proprietary, nor are they all technical. Managerial, organizational or interpersonal skills and judgment can also be critical. Whatever the domain of the deep smarts, however, a critical issue for organizational leaders is how such knowledge can be passed along to colleagues with less expertise. Since so much of the expertise is tacit-that is, not articulated or documented-and because it therefore exists mostly in the heads and hands of the experts, it can't be readily shipped from one brain to another.

In fact, Walter and I argue that deep smarts can't really be transferred at all. They must be re-created through the process of guided experience. Based on a three-year study of the transfer of knowledge between coaches and relative novices, we propose at least four kinds of guided experience: practice, observation, problem-solving and experimentation. The emphasis is on guided because all four of these produce deeper smarts in the learner when a knowledge coach interacts extensively with the novice, helping to plan, implement and review the learning experience.

Even the best athletes seek practice under the guidance of an expert coach. But two kinds of observation are also important: shadowing and mind-stretching. Shadowing, as the term suggests, is allowing junior staff to follow more experienced operators around, observing actions, speech, decision making-and then having them discuss their observations with the experts. A more provocative form of observation is to assign learners to a series of unusual experiences designed to challenge assumptions and enlarge worldviews. For example, when Best Buy top management determined that they needed to build an innovative capability in the company, they hired consultancy Strategos. The consultants' task was not the usual "analyze and report", but to coach teams of Best Buy employees through a series of mind-stretching experiences-including travel to destinations as diverse as computer game arcades in Seoul, Korea, and the American Girl store in Chicago (specializing in historical dolls). These direct experiences with foreign environments challenged team members' assumptions about the purpose and design of products, and led to some radically innovative ideas. For example, could Best Buy design a socially desirable place for communal use of computers that would have the powerful allure of a destination (such as American Girl) and (like the game arcades) attract a much younger set of users than usual?

Another mode of re-creating deep smarts is joint problem-solving by expert and protege. Deep smarts are, by their nature, contextual: Experts are often unaware of how they solve certain problems and cannot readily bring up a mental list of all possible strategies and outcomes. Their deep smarts are activated by the situation at hand. By working together, the proteges learn how the experts approach a problem-including using personal networks to narrow the search for information-and the experts often stretch their own mental boundaries.

Finally, guided experimentation is essential when there is no certain knowledge, as is so often the case with swift-changing technology and markets. The Best Buy teams mentioned earlier had to test their ideas out in small market experiments before they could judge their worth. Therefore, they opened a prototype "Bang" computer game arcade to teenagers and carefully observed what ideas worked, from helping customers mix to providing snack foods.

The solution to losing deep smarts, in short, is to invest in their re-creation. If the United States is not to lose its world preeminence, we suggest that we need to take the accelerating loss of such knowledge seriously and begin to staunch the flow.

Dorothy Leonard is the William Abernathy Professor of Business Administration Emerita at Harvard Business School. She can be reached at dleonard@hbs.edu. Please send your comments to Executive Editor Alison Bass at abass@cio.com.

Market Place
 

2008 CIO Summit

19th August, 2008 Four Seasons Hotel, Sydney Developed in partnership with CIO Magazine, IDC, INTEP and the CIO Executive Council.

The world of the CIO is extremely complex and diverse. Multiple priorities demand attention and decisions are needed instantly. Individual teams need to be driven towards common goals, and businesses strive to become more mobile, agile and responsive. For CIOs, the challenge never ends.

Every year the CIO Summit identifies what is top of mind for CIOs across Australia and New Zealand, and offers insight for CIO benchmarking and vendor strategic planning alike.

Recent IDC research shows that over 59% of CIO's believe that 'to achieve their business strategies, technology should be used more aggressively than today.'

Join us on August 19th to discover how this is possible with the latest technologies including Virtualisation, Web 2.0, IP Surveillance and Software as a Service (Saas).

Click here for registration.

Click here for more information.

Please email Denyse_Robertson@idg.com.au for further information.

  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #79: Brent D Taylor, author of The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires Part II 05 October, 2007 06:00:00

    For his new book, The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires, social researcher Brent D Taylor spent four years of intensive research investigating the psychological make-up and backgrounds of some of the world's richest men and women, including IT luminaries Bill Gates, Larry Ellison and Steve Jobs. Taylor discovered that, despite working in different industries and coming from different upbringings, they all have one thing in common -- they are all outsiders.
  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #78: Brent D Taylor, author of The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires 28 September, 2007 17:34:25

    For his new book, The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires, social researcher Brent D Taylor spent four years of intensive research investigating the psychological make-up and backgrounds of some of the world's richest men and women, including IT luminaries Bill Gates, Larry Ellison and Steve Jobs. Taylor discovered that, despite working in different industries and coming from different upbringings, they all have one thing in common -- they are all outsiders.
  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #77: Panasonic Speeds Up Trans-Pacific File Transfers, Part III 21 September, 2007 07:00:00

    Part three in our three-part special report from CIO's sister publication Network World in the US, as Paul Desmond reports from the Network World IT Roadmap Conference in Santa Clara, California. With development teams in the US and Japan, Panasonic needed a more efficient way to move very large files between the two locations. Iben Rodriguez, IT consultant for Panasonic Research and Development, explains how a storage-area network and virtual server technology helped speed up WAN performance.
  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #76: Panasonic Speeds Up Trans-Pacific File Transfers, Part II 14 September, 2007 07:00:00

    Part two in our three-part special report from CIO's sister publication Network World in the US, as Paul Desmond reports from the Network World IT Roadmap Conference in Santa Clara, California. With development teams in the US and Japan, Panasonic needed a more efficient way to move very large files between the two locations. Iben Rodriguez, IT consultant for Panasonic Research and Development, explains how a storage-area network and virtual server technology helped speed up WAN performance.
  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #75: Panasonic Speeds Up Trans-Pacific File Transfers, Part I 07 September, 2007 07:00:05

    Part one in our three-part special report from CIO's sister publication Network World in the US, as Paul Desmond reports from the Network World IT Roadmap Conference in Santa Clara, California. With development teams in the US and Japan, Panasonic needed a more efficient way to move very large files between the two locations. Iben Rodriguez, IT consultant for Panasonic Research and Development, explains how a storage-area network and virtual server technology helped speed up WAN performance.
  • +

    Best Western forced to play defense on data breach disclosure 29 August, 2008 08:08:00

    Could hotel chain have done a better job of defusing story about system intrusion?
    The headline in this week's Glasgow Sunday Herald -- "Revealed: 8 million victims in the world's biggest cyber heist" -- was a grabber.
  • +

    US Terror threat system crippled by technical flaws 28 August, 2008 09:53:00

    US Congress charges that US$500m project to prevent another 9/11 is a complete failure.
    A US House subcommittee is charging that a US$500 million IT project intended to "connect the dots" on terrorists and help prevent another 9/11 is a failure; it can't even handle basic Boolean search terms, such as "and, or and not."
  • +

    Malware infects space station laptops 28 August, 2008 08:15:00

    Not the first time, says NASA; astronauts load up Norton AntiVirus
    Malware has managed to get off the planet and onto the International Space Station, NASA confirmed yesterday. And it's not the first time that a worm or virus has stowed away on a trip into orbit.
  • +

    Separation of duties and IT security 28 August, 2008 09:40:00

    Muddied responsibilities create unwanted risk. Kevin Coleman says auditors may start labeling poorly defined IT duties as a material deficiency.
    Separation of duties is a key concept of internal controls and is the most difficult and sometimes the most costly one to achieve. This objective is achieved by disseminating the tasks and associated privileges for a specific security process among multiple people.
  • +

    How to recruit and retain the best young security employees 27 August, 2008 08:32:00

    Today's youngest generation of workers, known as Generation Y, have different career goals than their parents did. What do you need to know to get them to work for you?
    The final installment in a series of articles about generational differences and security. Part one looked at managing workers in different age groups. Part two examined the types of security concerns that are most commonly associated with different generations in the general workforce. This article provides recruiting and retention advice for security employees.
CIO Webcast Innovation #8 - What are the biggest roadblocks to IT's involvement in innovation at your company?
Watch the latest latest edition of CIO Innovation which is now available for download.
Watch the webcast
Sign up to the CIO Innovation update email


CIO Live Podcast #79: Brent D Taylor, author of The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires Part II
Listen to the latest edition of CIO Live which is now available for download.
Listen to the podcast
Sign up to the CIO Live email
Whitepaper

Using EMC Celerra IP Storage with Vmware Infrastructure 3 over iSCSI and NFS

Learn to tie virtualized computing to virtualized storage, to offer a dynamic set of capabilities within the data centre and create improved performance and system reliability. Discover how best to utilize EMC Celerra in a VMware ESX environment.

Sponsored Links