Friday | 9 January, 2009
CIO
Avoiding the TCO Trap
Using the total cost of ownership metric is a good way to measure costs but a bad way to analyze the full business value of IT investments
Jack Keen 07 April, 2004 14:07:29

But what is the total business value of our upgrade to the company? To find out, we need to add three non-TCO components of Full Business Value to our analysis. For the "systems effectiveness" component, we could quantify factors such as the ability to bring on entirely new applications, such as CRM, because the new servers and networks would have the needed functionality and capacity. For the "business efficiency" aspect of value, we might include the value of our reduced sales-force travel costs because of better, faster data from the advanced CRM solution made possible by an improved server and network infrastructure. For the fourth component, "business effectiveness", we could examine the tangible and intangible value of having a sales force capable of introducing more new products faster, again because of the capabilities of this advanced CRM system.

By using Full Business Value - not just TCO - to justify IT investments, you may not only uncover additional benefits that make the business case, but you may also boost IT's enterprise credibility by showing the non-IT executives that IT fully understands the scope of the company's operations.

If you suspect that TCO may be misused in your organization, here are three suggestions that can help you get the value analysis right.

1. Detect. Be alert to signs that you are too dependent on TCO for analysis. Warnings include: TCO is more than 25 percent of any value analysis and business case effort; TCO talk (rather than business value talk) dominates value analysis discussions; the terms TCO and ROI are used interchangeably; revenue-side benefits and intangibles are not used in business case justifications.

2. Recruit. If you feel a TCO-focus problem may exist, search out executive peers and other key influencers to gain their support for an enterprisewide value-culture upgrade. Ask for their help in convincing guardians of the investment decision-making process that while TCO plays an important role, there is much more required. Remind those who hesitate that visible, defensible and solid enterprise investment decision-making is a foundation of good IT and corporate governance (for example, Sarbanes-Oxley), Six Sigma quality processes and related initiatives.

3. Embed. Once you have political support for this value analysis makeover, establish and embed the FBV view within your company's IT investment decision-making processes. Help your IT selection committee insert these FBV explanations in their requirements for business case input. Develop business case templates, complete with clear documentation that visibly request such input, and explain how to find it. Establish value analysis training, complete with lots of examples of good and bad practices. Lastly, publicize early successes and look for ways to fine-tune the process as it goes forward.

TCO can uncover important benefits - but not total value. As with any good idea that has the potential to run amok, taking the time to use TCO appropriately is a key step to success.

Jack Keen is founder and president of the IT consultancy The Deciding Factor (www.decidingfactor.com) and co-author of Making Technology Investments Profitable: ROI Road Map to Better Business Cases

More about Gartner, Sigma
Featured Whitepaper Sponsors
Market Place
 

Smart SOA World Tour

Discover how SOA can create smarter outcomes for your business.

Attend and learn:

  • How SOA is helping leading companies to become more agile
  • Where you should be applying SOA processes in your company
  • The top SOA implementation mistakes to avoid

Click here for more information.
  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #79: Brent D Taylor, author of The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires Part II 05 October, 2007 06:00:00

    For his new book, The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires, social researcher Brent D Taylor spent four years of intensive research investigating the psychological make-up and backgrounds of some of the world's richest men and women, including IT luminaries Bill Gates, Larry Ellison and Steve Jobs. Taylor discovered that, despite working in different industries and coming from different upbringings, they all have one thing in common -- they are all outsiders.
  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #78: Brent D Taylor, author of The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires 28 September, 2007 17:34:25

    For his new book, The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires, social researcher Brent D Taylor spent four years of intensive research investigating the psychological make-up and backgrounds of some of the world's richest men and women, including IT luminaries Bill Gates, Larry Ellison and Steve Jobs. Taylor discovered that, despite working in different industries and coming from different upbringings, they all have one thing in common -- they are all outsiders.
  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #77: Panasonic Speeds Up Trans-Pacific File Transfers, Part III 21 September, 2007 07:00:00

    Part three in our three-part special report from CIO's sister publication Network World in the US, as Paul Desmond reports from the Network World IT Roadmap Conference in Santa Clara, California. With development teams in the US and Japan, Panasonic needed a more efficient way to move very large files between the two locations. Iben Rodriguez, IT consultant for Panasonic Research and Development, explains how a storage-area network and virtual server technology helped speed up WAN performance.
  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #76: Panasonic Speeds Up Trans-Pacific File Transfers, Part II 14 September, 2007 07:00:00

    Part two in our three-part special report from CIO's sister publication Network World in the US, as Paul Desmond reports from the Network World IT Roadmap Conference in Santa Clara, California. With development teams in the US and Japan, Panasonic needed a more efficient way to move very large files between the two locations. Iben Rodriguez, IT consultant for Panasonic Research and Development, explains how a storage-area network and virtual server technology helped speed up WAN performance.
  • +

    CIO Live Podcast #75: Panasonic Speeds Up Trans-Pacific File Transfers, Part I 07 September, 2007 07:00:05

    Part one in our three-part special report from CIO's sister publication Network World in the US, as Paul Desmond reports from the Network World IT Roadmap Conference in Santa Clara, California. With development teams in the US and Japan, Panasonic needed a more efficient way to move very large files between the two locations. Iben Rodriguez, IT consultant for Panasonic Research and Development, explains how a storage-area network and virtual server technology helped speed up WAN performance.
  • +

    Data breaches rose sharply in 2008, says study 08 January, 2009 08:27:00

    More than 35 million data records were breached in 2008, according to the Identity Theft Resource Center.
    More than 35 million data records were breached in 2008 in the U.S., a figure that underscores continuing difficulties in securing information, according to the Identity Theft Resource Center (ITRC).
  • +

    Rogue SSL certificate exploit puts VeriSign on the spot 07 January, 2009 11:04:00

    Wishes "white hat" researchers had notified VeriSign before public demo.
    Following the success of researchers last week in creating a false SSL certificate based on VeriSign's RapidSSL brand, the company is scrambling to explain how it happened, how it's preventing it from reoccurring, and whether its other SSL certificate-generation services are at risk.
  • +

    With Gaza conflict, cyberattacks come too 05 January, 2009 08:03:00

    Pro-Palestinian hackers have defaced thousands of sites following attacks in Gaza.
    The conflict raging in Gaza between Israel and Palestine has spilled over to the Internet.
  • +

    5 ways to secure your Blackberry 18 December, 2008 12:58:00

    What do Tom Cruise and the McCain campaign have in common? They have both been bitten by the loss of a Blackberry. Mobile expert Dan Hoffman gives advice on how to keep your cherished mobile device safe, even if it's out of your hands
    What do Tom Cruise and the McCain campaign have in common? They have both been bitten by the loss of a Blackberry. Mobile expert Dan Hoffman gives advice on how to keep your cherished mobile device safe, even if it's out of your hands.
  • +

    Wireless VPNs: Protecting the wireless wanderer 18 December, 2008 11:04:00

    Employees sipping café Java over their wireless laptops may think a VPN makes them safe and secure. With careful configuration, there's some chance they're right
    Employees sipping café Java over their wireless laptops may think a VPN makes them safe and secure. With careful configuration, there's some chance they're right.
CIO Webcast Innovation #8 - What are the biggest roadblocks to IT's involvement in innovation at your company?
Watch the latest latest edition of CIO Innovation which is now available for download.
Watch the webcast
Sign up to the CIO Innovation update email


CIO Live Podcast #79: Brent D Taylor, author of The Outsider's Edge: The Making of Self-Made Billionaires Part II
Listen to the latest edition of CIO Live which is now available for download.
Listen to the podcast
Sign up to the CIO Live email
Whitepaper

Solve Exchange Mailbox Storage Issues Once and for All

Join industry expert Bob Spurzem and Chuck Arconi of Fox Hollow to discover how to reduce Exchange total storage and keep it at a manageable level. Learn how Exchange storage growth can be contained without sacrificing security and accessibility.