Critical.
Authoritative.
Strategic.
Subscribe to CIO Magazine »

Battle for New VIC Government Tender

A Liberal Party shadow minister in Victoria has slammed the Labor ICT tendering process and demanded it starts giving local PC assemblers preference over interstate-based multinationals.

Shadow minister for education, Victor Perton, was scathing in his assessment of “a Luddite state government's” handling of ICT policy and tendering processes.

With applications now closed on a Victorian government tender for about $35 million worth of hardware, local companies are hopeful they will not lose out again to big brands.

Victoria's Department of Education and Training (DE&T) is in the process of evaluating responses from more than 15 companies.

A DE&T spokesperson said this “very important” tender would provide the “administration systems environment for schools” for three years.

The most keenly contested part of the tender is for 4150 desktop PCs, 1680 servers and 1700 laser printers, which sources estimate will cost a total of around $20-25 million. Additionally, a further $10-15 million will be spent on 1660 UPSs, 1660 LAN switches and associated products and services.

The tender closed in April, a decision should be made by July and delivery of equipment will commence in early February next year.

“I think that all of the leading industry groups and any of the local suppliers would tell you that the government sector in Victoria has a significant underspend in ICT,” Perton said.

He claimed there was "lots of rhetorical flourish but almost no performance on the ground” when it came to supporting the local ICT industry.

“Tender after tender is won by multinationals based interstate with almost no presence in Victoria other than sales staff looking for government and corporate ICT work,” Perton said. “It astonishes me that the government continues to disregard Victorian companies.”

Joel Schwalb is managing director of one local bidder, Melbourne-based PC systems and IT services company, Ipex. He agreed with Perton and said it was “about time the Victorian government considered the local industry more favourably”.

“There is a totally ridiculous aura that prevails about using multinationals in government contracts when it comes to PCs and servers,” Schwalb said. “There is not a single area where local companies can not compete. Not in quality, functionality, delivery or service. Recent Victorian education tenders for hardware have seen international companies awarded huge contracts in preference to local alternatives.

In November 2001, IBM was awarded a $92 million contract to supply 40,000 notebooks. Then in February last year, Acer won a $35 million deal to supply 21,000 desktops to what was then called the Department of Education, Employment and Training (DEET).

At the time these deals raised the hackles of Victorian PC companies who felt they were not being given a fair deal. Accusations were made that the state government was ignoring perfectly viable local options and awarding contracts to internationally owned, interstate-based monoliths with minimal commitment to Victorian investment that lowered prices beyond profitability to “buy” the business.

According to Schwalb, the tender processes which were in place were reasonable but had suffered serious management deficiencies.

“I think politicians have a genuine desire to see these contracts weighted towards local suppliers,” he said. “The problem is in defining how public servants are to arrive at a decision. It comes down to the whim of those in charge of that decision making process." Schwalb said the multinationals had vast resources to put into marketing their products including “wining and dining” departmental officials and advisers.

Other local companies tendering for the DE&T contract include Paragon Systems, TPG, ASI, Optima, Ocean Office Automation Omega Technology and Alpha Computers.

Neither IBM nor Acer would confirm or deny whether they were bidding for this contract. Sources claim both definitely had their hands up to do the deal direct, as did fellow multinationals Dell and HP.

Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

More about: Acer, DEET, Employment and Training, IBM, Ipex, Ocean Office Automation, Omega Technology, Optima, TPG

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Users posting comments agree to the CIO comments policy.
Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
Related Whitepapers
Latest Stories
Community Comments
Latest Blog Posts
Whitepapers
  • IDC Whitepaper: Generating Proven Business Value with EMC Next-Generation Backup and Recovery
    IDC interviewd ten companies that have deployed EMC backup and recovery solutions, including EMC Data Domain and EMC Avamar. Some of the customers also had EMC NetWorker. The purpose was to identify and quantify the resulting business value of each project, in order to calculate a cumulative return on investment. Read on.
    Learn more »
  • HP Security Action Plan for Enterprise Printing and Imaging
    Security is a part of how we work. When you walk through the front door of your office every morning, you probably pass a level of security. At your desk, it’s likely you log in to your computer and access files over a secure server. From security badges and ID cards to network firewalls and software security, it may seem like your organisation has taken every measure to protect its property, people and data. This action plan outlines a step-by-step approach to help you develop a plan that improves the security of your printing and imaging environment and boosts your business.
    Learn more »
  • Improving Productivity in the Connected Enterprise Through Collaboration
    In the market for collaborative applications, a large convergence is beginning to take hold, and the consumerization of IT is central to this movement. The technologies that people use as consumers are impacting the way employees, customers, and partners want to interact and collaborate at work. People want to take the same technology experiences that are available at home and plug them into their daily work lives. This movement is setting worker expectations as both employees and corporate consumers. Workers need to have the choice and flexibility to consume the applications they want, where they want, and on their preferred device. Read on.
    Learn more »
All whitepapers
rhs_login_lockGet exclusive access to Invitation only events CIO, reports & analysis.
Recent comments