If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, Apple has been flattering competitors for years. The company has famously copied, redesigned and reimagined many more products and services than it has ever invented.
Now Apple is taking a renewed interest in social media, as it prepares to introduce many of today's most popular messaging features in the next version of iOS. Maybe Apple can finally crack the code for social by doing what it does best: Mimicking other companies' technologies, incorporating them into its products and improving the user experience.
"Very flattering to see Apple 'borrow' numerous WhatsApp features into iMessage in iOS 8 #innovation," WhatsApp co-founder and CEO Jan Koum tweeted within hours of Apple's opening keynote at its annual developers conference last month. Never mind that many of WhatsApp's features were borrowed from other apps and services that came before it.
Koum may not see the irony in that because the lines between theft and flattery in business are defined by timing and perception. By the same token, only he knows what was on his mind when he wrote this as his second tweet ever in September 2011: "Is imitation still the sincerest form of flattery?"
One Company's Thief is Another Company's Genius
Apple is introducing so many changes and new features to iMessage that practically every messaging app on the planet could claim it's being copied to some extent or another. Self-destructing messages, location sharing, in-line audio and video messages, new swipe gestures and a major overhaul of group messaging are all on the menu for the next version of iMessage.
Calls, texts, video and photos are tasks that oftentimes require multiple apps for many users, says Doug Schumacher, co-founder of social media content strategy tool Zuum. "There's still plenty of room for innovation, and Apple's history of simplifying user experiences by minimizing things like buttons would seem well-suited to the task," he adds.
The evolution of messaging, social and mobile are inherent functionalities that became a natural extension for Apple with iMessage, says Altimeter Group principal analyst Brian Solis. "I don't know that it's necessarily Apple's intention to do anything in social. I think it's just making iOS 8 and iMessage a much more comprehensive platform that people can use without having to go to disparate apps," he says.
By integrating features enjoyed by users of WhatsApp, Snapchat and others into iMessage, Apple is enhancing value for new and future iOS users without brazenly competing against those startups, says Solis. "Competing at an app level is probably not worth Apple's time. And if it wanted to compete on an app level it would buy one of these. I think this is much more of a functionality standpoint to strengthen the overall universe," he adds.
Making iMessage More Robust for the Masses
"Single use (apps) is just a reflection of today's discombobulated digital society," says Solis, offering a day in the life scenario to help illustrate his point. "Right in front of you as you're walking on a beautiful afternoon is a mother duck and her little ducklings passing right before you in a nice single-file line. It's a moment that used to be one you would just stop and say 'ahh.' But now it's a moment that you have to capture and share. And in that moment you've got to make a decision: what app are you going to use? Is it Instagram, is it Facebook, is it Twitter, is it Vine, or is it a combination of all of these things?"
"It's almost like a basket-of-remotes problem, you have 30 different remote controls in your living room to control every device and it's overwhelming," Solis says. "So integration made sense, but single purpose makes sense when that's where your friends are. I know it sounds completely counterintuitive, but all of this stuff seems to be."
That network effect among friends, colleagues and family remains as long as these single purpose, frictionless apps keep their sense of cool, says Solis. "They all in some way, shape or form run their course, but what Apple does is each time it absorbs the good natures of these apps and makes it its own, which strengthens the bigger platform as the next trend is rising up."
Above all else, Apple needs to do what it's always done: Create a better user experience, says Schumacher. "If Apple doesn't make these changes, it's likely Google and Android will. WhatsApp and Snapchat have risen quickly, but for most mobile apps I don't think there are a lot of barriers to switching. That can work to Apple's advantage."
Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.