Leadership's tug of war
- 18 February, 2014 09:08
They are senior and strategic IT managers within their organisations. They cover the medical profession, education, engineering and property services, and banking. They firmly believe business skills are just as, if not more, important than technological ones. And they are also women.
The challenges facing women in IT have been discussed for years. They begin with technical subjects in primary and secondary school, and perhaps earlier.
Encouraging kids of any gender to do science and technology is difficult thanks to perceptions that both are too hard, too nerdish, and hold limited employment prospects.
These views extend into adulthood, but the differentiations evident between women and men become accentuated the higher up in the industry you go.
According to research issued by the Federation of Scientific and Technological Societies (now called Science and Technology Australia) in 2011, the plain fact is that at mid-career level, the number of women involved drops off. “It is rare to find women holding high-ranking positions in academia,” the research states.
The organisation cites the CSIRO, where 39 per cent of employees are female but only 8 per cent are at Level 8 (on a scale of 1 to 9). While this represents a 4.5 per cent increase over the past decade, “At this rate of increase it will take about 60 years until the number of women at Level 8 is equal to the level of [overall] female representation at CSIRO”.
Female engineers make up about 10 per cent of the workforce, the FASTS report says, but 77.8 per cent of them are in lower responsibility positions (Levels 1 to 3 on a scale of 5). The Learned Academies offer no good news either – their fellows, among the most eminent and respected scientists in the country, are overwhelmingly men.
Of the Fellows of the Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering, 9.8 per cent are women, while the Academy of Science has just seven per cent. In government, the technology divisions of the Defence Science and Technology Organisation (DSTO) have just 5 per cent female participation.
If getting women into science and technology is difficult, keeping them is even more so. A survey by the Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers Australia (APESMA) says the reason women leave their field include lack of flexible working conditions, lack of career development, workplace culture and pay inequality.
IT is no different, though the games environment may encourage more boys into the field. The latest figures from the Australian ICT Statistical Compendium, due to be published by the Australian Computer Society later this year, show the percentage of women employed in ICT occupations across all industries has increased to 169,400, or 28.34 per cent of the workforce. This is up 24.1 per cent from 2011.
However, the ratio changes significantly depending on the areas of ICT being studied, ranging from a participation figure of 16.94 per cent (13,000) in ICT trades, to 40.81 per cent (38,000) in ICT industry admin and logistics support. It drops to 24.5 per cent (53,500) in technical and professional occupations, but rises to 32.6 per cent (55,000) in ICT management and operations.
Women as IT managers
Arguably most worrying is that less than a third of ICT management is female. Some suggest the figure is even lower, especially as you move up in the ranks of management responsibility.
Michelle Beveridge, CIO for Open Universities Australia, claims to see less than 10 per cent female participation at ICT conferences for CIOs and senior managers.
“Either the women are not in the roles or they are not networking and working on their careers as well as the men. I suspect it is both.”
“IT is proving less and less attractive as a discipline for women,” says Anne Weatherston, group CIO for the ANZ Banking Group.
“This is a concern, given the importance and significance of technology in our world today. There are countless books and articles written about the value of increased representation of women at senior levels of organisations, and yet sadly the statistics point to the fact that the numbers are going the other way.”
There have been efforts in the past to encourage a different image of female IT workers, such as calendars of semi-clad “film goddesses” designed to counter the image of Plain Jane women in IT. Many times these have been derided as demeaning of women. The same criticisms have been applied to female-oriented award systems.
Most working women would prefer to be highly regarded more for their professional skills than their swimsuit style. But, nonetheless, there are barriers, and not just of the “women must do twice as well as men to be thought half as good” type. There are serious cultural and financial inequities too.
Despite an age where paid maternity leave is seen as a given, there is often a need for more formal schemes designed to encourage and entrench women in particular industries and roles, and such schemes have been endorsed by women, including those leading Future-State CIOs interviewed for this article.
Sarah Parton, general manager for business engagement, architecture, design and innovation with construction and property asset managers Transfield Services, claims she didn’t feel disadvantaged in her early years of working in IT at Accenture in the UK. “At the time I joined there was about a 60/40 men/women graduate intake, and a healthy mix of genders.
“Over the years the numbers thinned, particularly as women started having children and made alternative priority and lifestyle choices.
I led an initiative to increase the number of women returning to work after maternity leave from 55 to 80 per cent by introducing stay-in-touch days, pre- and post-maternity mentoring, paid leave for fertility treatment [which appears to be an occupational hazard for hard working career women who leave it later to start a family], nine months fully-paid maternity leave, opportunities for part-time work [for both mothers and fathers] and role modelling.
“We saw good results from this campaign, and other big organisations in the UK were undertaking similar exercises to retain their talented women.”
In Australia, however, Parton noticed a big difference, even though she was working for a big bank. “Maternity and paternity policies were archaic compared to Europe; there were very few women in senior roles and not a lot of impetus to change things,” she says.
“From my observations and commentary from peers, it also seems a very high proportion of CIOs are men and many recruit in their own image. In one particular organisation, the CIO recruited his skiing and drinking buddies who proudly displayed photos of themselves together in their offices.”
This concept of “hiring in your own image” is supported by Beveridge. “Without guidance, managers of a particular cohort will tend to hire people within the same cohort,” she says.
“In the ICT industry, that has contributed to the male majority perpetuating the male majority. It is often an unconscious thing, and it’s one of the reasons HR professionals have developed tools and techniques like behavioural interviewing.
Positive discrimination is an additional mechanism to broaden the candidate pool to include a representative group that is 50 per cent of the population using our products and services.”
Jennifer Biggin, IT manager for the Australian Medical Association (NSW), says the difference in percentages of male versus female should not be a killer issue.
“When I did my initial degree there were two other women in our final year of 120 students. Throughout my career I have always been in a male dominated IT environment.
“You can’t let that worry you – nor the endless need to have to show you know your subject each time you meet a new person.”
Weatherston hasn’t found the barriers for women in technology any different from other disciplines. The challenge for all companies, she says, is to assist women to rise through the ranks. As a way forward in IT, she cites several current moves in the UK and US to encourage girls to consider STEM (science, technology, engineering, mathematics) careers.
“In the US, there are non-profits such as the National Center for Women and Information Technology and ‘Girls Who Code’. The goal is to educate and inspire high-school girls and women to consider careers in information technology. There are similar initiatives in Australia including ‘Go Girl IT’ and ‘Women in IT’. “But the jury is still out.”
ANZ, she says, has set targets for at least 40 per cent female representation among participants in its key recruitment, talent and development programs. It also has a medium-term goal to achieve at least 40 per cent representation of women in management overall.
“I owe my early career step up to an organisation that worked really hard to identify and nurture talent regardless of sex, colour, religion or disability,” Weatherston says. “Good people and specifically good leaders are in short supply; we must work harder at identifying and building talent.”
This concept is particularly strong for women looking for role models and, more personally, direct mentors.
Biggin and Beveridge agree having good women as mentors early in their careers helped. “It was difficult to find female mentors, and I often worked with teams where I was the only female,” Beveridge says.
“There have been times when managing a technical team was difficult because the boys thought a woman, let alone one with an accounting background as I have, couldn’t possibly understand technology. There was always that little extra I had to do to earn credibility and respect.
Happily, I have seen attitudes change. Increasingly I hear male CIOs lamenting the lack of females in their teams and recognising the value diversity brings to team dynamics and effectiveness.”
It all starts at the top, says Parton, and not with words but with action and role modelling. “A very successful senior woman I know working in wealth management has a high performing team who are predominantly women.
She told me her team had come up with a core principle by which they would operate, that ‘we have got each other’s backs’, which I thought that was amazing and inspirational,” she says.
“Imagine a leadership team that works as a united group - no wonder they are so successful. I compared that to the predominantly male leadership teams I have worked with and for and thought of the occasions I witnessed a real lack of cooperation, the establishment of fiefdoms and the battles of egos.”
Ultimately, it’s about being the best fit and demonstrating confidence. For management and society generally, Weatherston says that means obtaining a better understanding of the barriers to women’s progress and “doing everything we can to remove them”.
“There is now new and pretty consistent material emerging that shows the two major impediments to women’s progress are, firstly, self confidence and belief as women set high standards for themselves; and secondly, unconscious biases that they encounter in the workplace. If we can help women overcome those two barriers to success, the rest will follow.”
Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.
Five trends affecting legal CIOs
CIO Roundtable: The changing face of security
Bitcoin malware count soars as cryptocurrency value climbs
Bouncing Back From CIO Unemployment
Union slams latest fibre-to-premise trial in Tasmania
451 Group Research Report MDM Trends
As the BYOD model continues to grow at twice the rate of corporate-owned devices, enterprises are facing an increasingly diversified mobility landscape. And though BYOD brings many benefits, complex management and security challenges are also ushered in. Read this report to understand what MDM can and cannot do for you and which solutions are being chosen today - and tomorrow.
Best Practices in Data Protection Monitoring
This whitepaper discusses best practice in data protection monitoring, with a focus on recoverability and visibility as significant drivers for success. Whether backing up a private cloud or several smaller environments, learn how a unified view is necessary for proactively reporting protection, compliance to auditors, and understanding overall data protection health, performance, and reliability.
How to Successfully Select an ERP System
An Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system is a series of software applications that collect and compiles data from different departments to enhance collaboration and co-ordination within the business. If you’re looking to implement your first ERP system, or to upgrade from an existing system, this whitepaper offers eight simple steps for selection that will lead to long-term strategic success.