Backhaul blues: Uncertain future for NBN competition in Tasmania
- 20 November, 2012 11:00
- Comments
The cost of backhaul from Tasmania to the mainland of Australia for the National Broadband Network could hamper competition among retail service providers (RSPs) in the state, several industry players say.
James Spenceley, CEO at Vocus Communications, says while the company is looking to build backhaul for the NBN on a national basis, it currently does not make financial sense for the company to provide backhaul from Melbourne to Hobart due to its cost.
He says it was cheaper to move traffic from Sydney to LA up to five years ago than it is to move traffic from Melbourne to Hobart.
NBN rollout: Can I connect to the NBN?
“The cost to set it up and the amount people that would use it when the cost is that high is so small – we couldn’t make it stack up," he says.
“There’s just no competition … They have no incentive to actually increase the usage down there. I think it’s been a struggle for a lot of people for a long time.”
Tasmania is serviced by three cables connecting the state to the mainland – Basslink, which is owned by Basslink Telecom, and Telstra’s two Bass Strait fibre links.
ISPs only need one cable to connect to the mainland. However, to provide redundancy a second cable is required, which means purchasing backhaul from Telstra.
Prices for backhaul from Tasmania to the mainland were set by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) in June 2012.
In its final access determination (FAD) for domestic transmission capacity service (DTCS), the ACCC ruled (PDF) a 40 per cent uplift in prices for backhaul from Tasmania to Melbourne was warranted due to the higher cost of providing services over a submarine cable.
“Services to Tasmania are regarded as regional services because of their location, traffic density, demand and the need for submarine cable connection…” the ACCC stated in its report.
“These services carry traffic through Hobart in the south and, to a lesser extent, Launceston in the north. ACCC analysis found that the average price of submarine routes is 39 per cent higher than mainland inter-capital routes. The FAD therefore provides a 40 per cent increase of the price of a 300km cable for DTCS routes from the mainland to Tasmania.”
However, in its submission, Telstra argued against that the “Commission must set prices in the FAD that do not prevent an efficient service provider supplying the highest quality service from obtaining a normal rate of return on its investment.
“The proposed uplift factor of 40 per cent fails to achieve this, as it fails to recognise the increased costs incurred with supplying a geographically diverse submarine cable across the Bass Strait. Further, if the Commission were to set an FAD price for the highest quality service provider that does not properly account for the higher costs of geographic path protection, higher quality service providers will be unable to recoup the costs of providing a higher quality service.”
Recommended
Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.
- Bookmark this page
- Share this article
- Got more on this story? Email CIO
- Follow CIO on twitter
-
Australia suspected to have PRISM data: Ludlam
-
Australia Post’s mail business to lose $200 million this year
-
Australia Post’s mail business to lose $200 million this year
-
Microsoft's ambivalence about Office on the Web gives Apple shot with iWork on iCloud
-
3 Lessons Learned From a Failed Customer Feedback Test
-
The SPARC Difference - Reduce Risks, Cut Costs, Power Innovation
Despite current economic factors, IT investment continues to be fueled by the need for better and more agile IT capabilities to support an enterprise’s business strategy, as well as to keep up with the rapidly changing demands of the ‘always-on’ user. However, budgets are squeezed and executives are under pressure to reduce capital expenditure and streamline administrative costs. A key strategy is to consolidate and refresh existing IT infrastructures. In this whitepaper, compliments of Remora, find out what technology can add value and enable you to change the shape of your IT budget and, to transform IT into a force for change and innovation. -
Android Malware Exposed
Take an in-depth look at the evolution of android malware. The world of malware targeting the Android OS is similar yet very different from malware affecting Windows. Explore the rapidly evolving world of android malware and shed light on the various techniques used to exploit devices using this OS. -
Process Automation – What the Best CIOs Ask
In the current economic and regulatory environment, there is significant pressure on today’s CIO to not only keep the business running within an allocated budget, but to actively transform a business through the smart deployment of technology. Find out what questions the best CIOs ask and answer when transforming their businesses with process automation.
Get exclusive access to Invitation only events CIO, reports & analysis. 
