Managed services fails to deliver: IDC study
- 04 October, 2012 15:44
Some managed service providers are not fully meeting the total cost of ownership (TCO) and return on investment (ROI) expectations of their customers, according to an IDC study.
The study, Managed Services and Why Choose a Telco: A Snapshot of Australian Business, found that 23 per cent of 100 Australian IT managers and decision makers surveyed have incurred an increase in costs under a managed services provider.
“That’s one of the highest figures in the entire region of Asia-Pacific — it’s higher than New Zealand, and the only place higher is Malaysia. Everywhere else, like Singapore for example, it's at 5 per cent,” said IDC Australia associate research director Dustin Kehoe.
“Some C-level [executives] want [ROI/TCO] within three months, six months, and most want it definitely within nine months… 44 per cent are saying costs have increased or costs have stayed the same. That means only 56 per cent have achieved cost savings.”
Kehoe said a “misalignment” and not being “realistic” in expectations are the main reasons for why cost reduction goals are not being fully met. He said it could be the doing of both the service provider and the customer.
“There’s some kind of misalignment between what [the vendor] is selling as a service provider and what the customer’s expectation is,” he said.
“It’s very difficult to deliver, even if you put it all in the cloud, any project that has, for example, a TCO metric of less than six months return. The way that most providers are able to map around this is to [decide on] a realistic time frame of a few years and within specific metrics."
However, this misalignment could be the customer's fault, according to Kehoe. He said that if price is the only criterion or one of two criteria an organisation uses to select a managed services provider, then this could potentially be a flawed model.
"In the short term it’ll give you the best price, but there are so many hidden costs behind that," he said. "If it's all about the transaction and price and squeezing your suppliers, then you will pay because the moment something breaks, the moment that you need to move, add, change delete… that’s when you are locked into a contract and the supplier plays the game of taking the money back.”
Despite the fact that nearly half of respondents had not achieved cost savings with their managed services provider, the survey showed that 75 per cent of respondents will increase their spending on managed services or spend the same amount in the next 12 months.
Kehoe said that investment in managed services is going to continue because IT departments recognise that they need to start freeing up their time to focus on innovation rather than ‘keeping the lights on’.
“IT is getting more and more complex and the more you hand off to a trusted provider the more things you can do strategically to focus on other areas,” he said.
Follow Rebecca Merrett on Twitter: @Rebecca_Merrett
Download the CIO Australia iPad app CIO Australia for iPad
Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.
Why change management doesn’t work
Larry Page wants to see your medical records
Dual-Persona Smartphones Not a BYOD Panacea
After two-year hiatus, EFF accepts bitcoin donations again
CIOs struggle to deliver timely mobile business apps: survey
ESG Whitepaper: Integrated Computing Platform Survey
Data centres, servers, storage and more are being combined for simplified management and cost savings. In this survey, ESG looks at the current and future trends surrounding today’s integrated computing solutions. Download to find out how organisations are more likely to see commit IT budgets to the purchase of integrated solutions. Read more.
Devising a Server Protection Strategy with Trend Micro
With so many Information Technology solutions available to choose from today, many organizations put their trust in the experience, insight and advice of Gartner, and their industry-leading analysts. Trend Micro’s portfolio of solutions meets and exceeds Gartner’s recommendations on how to devise a server protection strategy. Precisely how Trend Micro does it is detailed in this whitepaper. Read now.
BYOD and Beyond - Implementing a Unified Access Solution
The rise of BYOD programs is the single most radical shift in the economics of client computing for business since PCs invaded the workplace. Whether you are contemplating the creation of a BYOD program or currently trying to establish one, this fact cannot be overstated. Find out how to overcome these challenges.