Apple-Samsung jury extends deliberations
- 23 August, 2012 17:54
As it begins a second day of deliberations in the Apple v. Samsung patent battle, the jury charged with evaluating the case has decided to work an extra hour.
The nine-person jury had been scheduled to work from 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. local time, taking lunch at the San Jose courthouse, and followed that schedule on their first day of deliberations. But going into their work on Thursday, they indicated to the court they would be staying an extra hour. The court released this information to reporters.
It's impossible to know what's going on inside the jury room and the reason for their decision -- the jury is strictly limited in whom they can speak to about this case -- but there are a couple of possibilities, according to Roy Futterman, a director at DOAR Litigation Consulting and a clinical psychologist who works on trial strategies and the mindset of jurors.
"The first is that the jury has decided it's very complicated and they have taken it upon themselves to have more time, to hunker down and get into the details," Futterman said.
"This is the most likely reason. They know they have a lot of work and they've said, 'let's do it.' They are probably relieved to be able to talk to each other and get down to work after three weeks of listening. It's a sign they are up for [the work]."
"The other possibility is that they want to get it over with. It's not likely, but they might want to spend more time on this so they can be done by the weekend," he said.
Futterman said juries asking for more time to deliberate isn't unheard of but it is a little unusual.
"A lot of time, people think juries are eager to get out of there. I think this shows they are taking their job very seriously."
The case revolves around seven Apple patents -- four covering design elements and three covering the way devices work -- and five Samsung patents related to cellular technology. Apple is accusing Samsung and two of its subsidiaries of infringement on almost 30 handsets, and the jury needs to come up with rulings on each phone and each company.
As a result they have a complex verdict form that demands more than 700 individual decisions be made. Before they sat down to begin deliberations they received 109 pages of jury instructions, which took more than two hours to read to them in court earlier this week.
The case is 11-01846, Apple v. Samsung, at the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California in San Jose.
Martyn Williams covers mobile telecoms, Silicon Valley and general technology breaking news for The IDG News Service. Follow Martyn on Twitter at @martyn_williams. Martyn's e-mail address is firstname.lastname@example.org
Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.
- Getting Real About Security Management and Big Data – A Roadmap for Big Data in Security Analytics
- Managing the Rapid Rise in Database Growth: 2011 IOUG Survey on Database Manageability
- 2013 Global Information Security Survey: Initial findings
- Agentless Security for Virtual Environments
- Advanced Persistent Threats and Real-Time Threat Management
Why change management doesn’t work
Larry Page wants to see your medical records
Dual-Persona Smartphones Not a BYOD Panacea
After two-year hiatus, EFF accepts bitcoin donations again
CIOs struggle to deliver timely mobile business apps: survey
The Power of Cloud
Although cloud is widely recognized as a technology game changer, its potential for driving business innovation remains virtually untapped. To take advantage of cloud’s potential to transform internal operations, customer relationships and industry value chains, organisations need to determine how best to employ cloud-enabled business models that promote sustainable competitive advantage. Learn more about driving business model innovation.
A Holistic Approach to your BYOD Challenge
More and more enterprises are seeing significant benefits from allowing employees to choose the device they use to get their jobs done, and are adopting bring your own device (BYOD) initiatives. While the BYOD trend increases flexibility and productivity, it introduces a host of new challenges for your IT administrators. Click for more!
Cloud Computing for Midsize Businesses: Delivering Innovation and Efficiency
It’s time for midsize companies to start thinking differently about infrastructure. This white paper provides a brief overview of cloud computing, explains how midsize companies can benefit, and describes the steps they can take to take advantage of what it has to offer. Read now.