Critical.
Authoritative.
Strategic.
Subscribe to CIO Magazine »

Film giants begin illegal downloads appeal

The case continues in the High Court

A consortium of film studio giants has begun a High Court appeal against internet service provider (ISP) iiNet over illegal downloads.

The companies, headed by Roadshow Films, initially took action against iiNet in the Federal Court alleging it failed to take steps to stop its customers from illegally downloading movies and TV shows.

In February 2010, the court found in favour of iiNet.

An appeal by the movie giants in the Federal Court earlier this year also failed.

Counsel for the film companies Tony Bannon, SC, told the full bench of the High Court on Wednesday that authorising someone to infringe copyright was itself an act of infringing copyright.

He said ISPs do not pass on a warning to users that they may be breaching copyright.

"They (ISPs) don't have to pass on the warning," Bannon said.

"Our case is ... if they don't do it then they're authorising it."

Bannon said prosecutions for copyright infringements had only ever been brought against people who supplied multiple copies of material.

"The cost-benefit analysis of pursuing an individual case against one individual user for downloading three films or three records would be a use of the judicial system which the court would not be wildly enthusiastic about," he said.

"The very fact that it is so unworkable and so implausible and so illogical and costly ... that's an in-built protection for users themselves.

"They know the rights office can't track down everybody."

Chief executive of iiNet, Michael Malone, said on Tuesday he was confident the High Court would reaffirm the Federal Court's earlier judgments and clear the company of copyright breaches.

"Those judgments demonstrated that the allegations against us were proven to be unfounded," he said in a statement.

Malone said iiNet continued to stand ready to work with the movie and internet industry to develop, implement and promote new ways to protect copyright and educate consumers.

In the initial case, the studios had tried to prove iiNet not only failed to take steps to stop illegal file-sharing by customers but breached copyright itself by storing the data and transmitting it through its system.

The case will continue in the High Court on Thursday.

Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

More about: Counsel, iiNet

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Users posting comments agree to the CIO comments policy.
Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
Related Coverage
Related Whitepapers
Latest Stories
Community Comments
Tags: copyright infringement, Federal Court of Australia, high court, High Court of Australia, iinet, iinet Michael Malone, illegal downloading, internet service providers (ISPs), Michael Malone, Roadshow Films
Latest Blog Posts
Whitepapers
  • Three simple steps to better patch security
    It’s estimated that 90% of successful attacks against software vulnerabilities could be prevented with an existing patch or configuration setting. Yet patching is a persistent challenge for IT managers. With the glut of patches released each year, how do you know which ones are truly critical security patches and which ones aren’t? And how can you identify which computers are actually missing the patches they need? This paper details a simple approach to patching that gives you better visibility into and control over patch assessment and compliance.
    Learn more »
  • Oracle Business Process Analysis Suite
    Careful analysis and continuous optimization of business processes delivers real competitive advantage. Conversely, a random approach to process design negatively impacts a company’s bottom line. This insight is one reason successful companies adopt business process management (BPM) as a way of aligning their business processes with business and customer requirements. Success with BPM eliminates the gap between business strategy and implementation. Business users are empowered to participate in all stages of the business process lifecycle. Closed-loop integration between modeling, execution, and monitoring enables continuous and holistic business process improvement.
    Learn more »
  • Magic Quadrant for Managed Print Services, Worldwide
    Gartner's managed print services (MPS) Magic Quadrant is a useful starting point for identifying and evaluating MPS providers. It is intended for Gartner's client base of mainly midsize and large organisations, many of which operate throughout two or more regions, and some of which are truly global. Although not all MPS projects are multiregional or global at the outset, customers often choose to scale up one region at a time. In this way, they can manage their office printing in a unified manner globally. Read more.
    Learn more »
All whitepapers
rhs_login_lockGet exclusive access to Invitation only events CIO, reports & analysis.