Subscribe to CIO Magazine »

Government promises of NBN pricing 'unattainable': Internode

National Broadband Network business model criticised for large overhead costs


Internode has slammed the government’s cost pricing of the National Broadband Network (NBN), saying that NBN Co's business model and concentrating virtual circuit (CVC) pricing are financially unviable.

Internode yesterday released its pricing plan, with the cheapest plan offered set to cost $59.95 per month for a phone and internet bundle on a 12/1Mbps connection with a 30GB data allowance.

Internode head Simon Hackett wrote in blog post that the ISP is concerned the Gillard government won't be able to meet its commitment to end users paying similar prices to current ADSL2+ and phone service bundles and uniform national pricing.

“A number of pressure points in the wholesale pricing model exist which will make these promises from the government untenable in practice,” Hackett wrote.

“NBN Co, in my view, have not yet properly addressed the full lifetime impact of the costs of the participation by RSPs [retail service providers] across the built period.”

The CVC was also a concern for Hackett, who wrote that its cost construct will generate large overhead costs for RSPs while it is priced at the wholesale plan rate of $20 per megabit per month fee.

“A simple change to the pricing model (first 200 megabits of CVC included at no extra cost) would solve this almost entirely,” he claimed.

“…Internode discovered the necessity of this in practice during its pioneering work in the Tasmanian NBN initial deployment. We operated with a 100 megabit CVC size at first, and rapidly ran into unacceptable performance issues with our 100 megabit connected school customers.”

Expressing concerns that overhead costs would restrict RSPs from participating in the NBN, Hackett claimed that without reassessing the pricing structure, the ISP market would disenfranchise smaller ISPs.

“This then delivers a genuine level playing field in terms of effective per-user wholesale access cost for RSPs by removing the punitive long-term cost overhead that will otherwise exist.”

Malcolm Turnbull used Hackett’s comments about uniform national pricing and the release of Internode's proposed retail pricing for NBN plans to launch an attack against the Government.

"If the government can’t deliver on a crucial promise made to the country independents after the election about national uniform pricing, then I would advise those independents to revisit their decision to support this Government," Turnbull said

Earlier this week Turnbull claimed that the Coalition would deliver faster broadband than offered under the NBN, if elected at the 2013 federal election.

Follow Lisa Banks on Twitter: @CapricaStar

Follow Computerworld Australia on Twitter: @ComputerworldAu

Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

More about: CVC, etwork, Internode
References show all




So this means the the NBN is double the cost for customers. Internodes current price for adsl2+ is $29.95.



So Paul, comment 1..are you telling me you can get a internet/phone bundle for $29.95?

Comments are now closed.
Related Coverage
Related Whitepapers
Latest Stories
Community Comments
Tags: Simon Hackett, Malcolm Turnbull, Networking, internode, National Broadband Network (NBN), broadband
Latest Blog Posts
  • Don’t Rip and Replace - Wrap and Renew!
    The abundance of legacy applications in the contact centre can trap a business into rigid, inefficient processes and introduce undue complexity. A unified, omni-channel desktop can transform customer experience without the cost and complexity of rip and replace. This whitepaper explains how companies can save time and money by taking advantage of existing resources in a new way.
    Learn more »
  • Case Study: Steel Blue
    Read how Perth-based safety footwear manufacturer, Steel Blue, was able to cut costs with shipping and improve efficiency while meeting the growing demand for their products as they expanded their national and export markets and increased their local market share, all thanks to a new ERP system.
    Learn more »
  • Rebranded Quadmark revamps its IT solutions with Google Apps
    The Singapore office was using Exchange as its email server but encountered various issues such as storage capacity limitations and difficulty in managing spam. Adding new users to the server was also a hassle that often required a third party vendor, resulting in a waste of time and resources. Quadmark also experienced email performance issues that slowed down their employees’ response time, leading to frustration among staff and clients. Quadmark’s management felt that it was unacceptable to continue it’s current solution and thus decided to streamline its IT infrastructure alongside its rebranding plans. The business wanted a unified and consolidated email service for its various offices. Quadmark also wanted to be able to house files and documents on the cloud.
    Learn more »
All whitepapers
rhs_login_lockGet exclusive access to Invitation only events CIO, reports & analysis.
Latest Jobs
Salary Calculator

Supplied by

View the full Peoplebank ICT Salary & Employment Index

Recent comments