Critical.
Authoritative.
Strategic.
Subscribe to CIO Magazine »

Gaps remain in local cybercrime law: Professor

Vague legislation around traditional trespass, fraud and theft crimes leave room for translation in an online environment

While Australian crime legislation has been amended to account for the evolving landscape of cybercrime, gaps remain in the key areas of theft, fraud and trespass, according to University of Technology (UTS) director of Communications Law Centre, Professor Michael Fraser.

Opening the Australian Federal Police’s (AFP) annual High Tech Crime Conference this week, Fraser commended the work done so far, but pointed to the gaps requiring further work.

“Commonwealth and the State crimes acts have been amended to include technology-specific crimes into legislation such as corruption, denials of service and spam, but there remain numerous instances where the Crimes Act may not provide adequate relevance,” he told conference attendees. “Traditional criminal laws of trespass, fraud and theft are not technologically neutral and run the risk of being ineffectual in the face of unique factual circumstances commonly seen in cybercrimes.”

As a result, Fraser said, those affected by such attacks in an online environment couldn’t rely on existing legislation and had to turn to other forms of legal recourse in order to resolve the issue.

AFP High Commissioner, Tony Negus, touted the reach of current Australian laws in opposition to those currently in place elsewhere.

“Some of the legislation in countries around the world doesn’t stack up with what we have in Australia, the US and the UK so it’s a challenge to work with the Eastern European countries, to try and bring them up to speed with what needs to happen to protect children in those areas as well,” he said.

However, Fraser said amendments to legislation were still required to keep up with the evolving threat landscape of cybercrime.

“As we have seen in the last five to ten years, the unique cyberspace environment has begun to challenge and stretch the traditional doctrines which are beginning to distort the issues and perhaps even frustrate the prosecution of cybercrime.”

Negus admitted that the nature of cybersecurity meant law enforcement agencies were continually playing catch up to meet the new threats posed by those who committed cybercrimes, particularly as traditional crimes and cybercrimes were often intertwined to some degree. The failure of international law - particularly in Eastern Europe - to meet Australian standards also limited the local capacity to act, according to Negus, as many of the attacks originated from overseas.

“The Virtual Globe Taskforce which the AFP chairs [is] a group of countries across the world who are committed to preventing child abuse in the online environment,” he said.

Fraser acknowledged international recognition of the issues, but said there would always be a lag in ratifying conventions and implementing local legislation.

The High Tech Crime Conference coincides with National Child Protection Week, which has seen the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) implement activities such as the Cybersmart Detectives program to promote security awareness and potential issues among children and parents.

Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

More about: Australian Federal Police, Communications Law Centre, Federal Police, UTS

Comments

1

Rick Bennett

Wed 27/10/2010 - 09:44

Australia has a unique history of "independent activism" that might foster my cyber privateer law, wherein Australia could issue LETTERS OF MARQUE AND REPRISAL to licensed and bonded Cyber Privateers to "loot the looters." It's not likely that the U.S. has the political stomach to take on the world of cyber criminals and rogue governments, but this could become the "big new cash crop" for Australia.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Users posting comments agree to the CIO comments policy.
Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
Related Coverage
Related Whitepapers
Latest Stories
Community Comments
Tags: Australian Federal Police, High Tech Crime, University of Technology
Latest Blog Posts
Whitepapers
  • Business Intelligence Best Practices for Dashboard Design
    Even if a dashboard’s appearance looks professional and is aesthetically pleasing, appearances can be deceiving. Although visual design is important, it is also important to ask yourself: Is the data reliable? Is it timely? Is any data missing? Is it consistent across all dashboards?. This paper offers an overview of best practice business intelligence (BI) dashboard design principles and discusses data integration options for getting data into a dashboard.
    Learn more »
  • Oracle Exadata: Extreme Performance Lowest Cost
    As organisations contend with escalating demands for greater quantities of information, more sophisticated data analysis, and a burgeoning user population, Oracle Exadata makes database workloads faster, easier to manage, and less expensive. Oracle Exadata is the world’s first database machine to provide extreme performance for both data warehousing and online transaction processing (OLTP) applications.
    Learn more »
  • Six tips for choosing a unified threat management (UTM) solution
    As network security grows more complex, businesses are demanding the simplicity of unified threat management (UTM). Businesses like yours are replacing multiple, outdated and costly appliances from different vendors with a single, reliable UTM solution. The best solutions offer a more powerful way to manage network security today and in the future. UTM also promises to slash your network security management efforts and hardware costs. This whitepaper offers you detailed advice on how to choose the comprehensive unified threat management (UTM) that best suits your business.
    Learn more »
All whitepapers
rhs_login_lockGet exclusive access to Invitation only events CIO, reports & analysis.
Recent comments