Critical.
Authoritative.
Strategic.
Subscribe to CIO Magazine »

In Pursuit of the Technical Contact

Too many companies have forgotten that automation is intended to take care of the ordinary class of problem-and that humans are a necessary ingredient for uncommon scenarios. The result is poor software usability, particularly for the developers, techies and admins who actually do know how to operate a computer.

Let me give you a fer-instance.

My personal (non-work) mail server is set up with rather strenous levels of spam-fighting, so I sometimes get complaints from people who have misbehaving mail servers, and the occasional bounce from poorly run e-newsletters. It usually isn't a problem, once I reach the right individual, since it can be resolved simply by the user (who ought to be taught to send mail properly in the first place) or by the admins (who may not know they're breaking the rules; ignorance, fortunately, is curable).

But sometimes, there isn't a human available to correspond with. I received the New York Times e-newsletter for years, but it unaccountably stopped arriving. We've checked the mail server logs; the New York Times newsletter hasn't even attempted to deliver for several months. The company's site has no way to tell them so. One of my credit card companies insists that my e-mail ID is invalid; in actual fact, Capital One's SPF record is broken but the site has no way to tell the company that they're the bozos.

Similarly, [US Online DVD rental company] Netflix has decided that my e-mail ID is invalid, and regularly displays a message direly instructing me to fix the situation immediately. (Not that it keeps movies from arriving at my door. That still works.) Netflix's Help text is written for ordinary users, for perfectly good reasons:

If you get this message, it means that we are not able to contact you via the email address you have provided us. You may want to check and update your email address. If your email address is correct, you should add Netflix to the 'safe senders list' in your email or spam blocking system. The addresses you should add are info@netflix.com and discship@netflix.com.

And I'm cool with that. For most end-users, that's the right message, even if it places the blame on the user. My issue is that there's no place to click when your response is, "Tried that. Didn't work." (And, incidentally, Netflix.com has not attempted to send any messages whatsoever for the last few months, although I did re-enter my e-mail ID just-in-case.) Netflix kindly gives me a telephone number for me to call, but frankly, I rarely pick up the phone these days; and that's not the point, anyhow.

What I want a site to do is offer the basic user information, such as the text that Netflix offered above. But there should be a link for "I tried that; now what?" that bumps me to the next level of support. When an error message says, "Contact your administrator," I should also see a link for those who say, "I'm the administrator, and I sure can't figure out what the problem is." That is: I want a way for a technical person to contact a technical person. Too few sites have no way to do so.

Since those companies are the ones send out bulk e-mail (solicited, in this case) they are also the ones most likely to be added to a black list somewhere. The fact that their errors and fixes tend to blame the user rather than to say, "Here's where to go to let us know we may have a problem" is a serious weakness.

This isn't the fault of the software development team, who is just following the site spec. It is, however, a problem with the way that too many sites are designed. And that's just plain wrong.

Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

More about: Capital One, Netflix, VIA

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Users posting comments agree to the CIO comments policy.
Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
Related Whitepapers
Latest Stories
Community Comments
Latest Blog Posts
Whitepapers
  • Enterprise Buyers Guide for Printers
    Every enterprise owns, and regularly replaces, printers, copiers, multifunctional products and fax machines. The problem most face is not too few choices, but too many. How do you even begin to select the right one? Here is the Computerworld guide to buying a printer for the enterprise.
    Learn more »
  • Consolidating Applications with Oracle Solaris Containers
    The main focus in IT departments today is increasing service levels while reducing the cost of the IT infrastructure. To reduce costs, businesses are eager to consolidate applications onto fewer servers, but they must be careful to isolate these applications to provide adequate resources and security. Read on
    Learn more »
  • Case Study: HJ Heinz
    Heinz has trusted Sophos to protect its desktop users and email systems from malware and spam for many years. As part of its multi-tier approach to IT security, the company needed more robust protection against web-based threats and the use of unauthorised applications.
    Learn more »
All whitepapers
rhs_login_lockGet exclusive access to Invitation only events CIO, reports & analysis.