CIO
Microsoft's Vista Plan: Throw More Lipstick on the Pig
Bernard Golden  22 February, 2008 11:54:57

There's a deep irony in last week's announcement that Microsoft's head of Windows marketing, Michael Sievert, has "left the company," corporate-speak for "been dumped." At least they didn't add the killer clause "to pursue other interests," corporate-speak for "dumped with enthusiasm."

This move is traditional for under-performing tech companies. Marketing gets blamed and the head of Marketing gets walked off the gangplank.

The irony is thinking that somehow different marketing would convince more customers to purchase a product, whereas the evidence is that marketing has minimal effect on adoption. In the tech world, if the product helps people do their job better, it can find a home. Absent a pressing need, no one will bother. The most important factor in making a product decision is ... the product!

It's tempting to think that a new spin will somehow make potential customers see the light. In a way, changing the marketing is almost like blaming the customer for just not being smart enough to understand why he/she/it should buy. "We'll tweak the messaging to highlight the items we haven't communicated well." In reality, it's never the communication, it's the product -- but it's easier (and cheaper) to change ads than it is to admit the product is inadequate and needs to be changed. Moreover, firing Marketing makes it look like the vendor is doing something to address its marketplace problems.

Without rehashing the myriad criticisms of Vista, Microsoft's main problem is that there is a perfectly acceptable alternative already in use with most potential customers: XP. And Vista does not provide sufficient improvement to justify the license cost and work required to migrate.

It wasn't like that for XP. People adopted it quite rapidly, because it was significantly better than the previous Microsoft version. Thinking that the reason Vista isn't being adopted is because it needs better marketing is a serious misperception about the realities of day-to-day technology use.

The countervailing example that reinforces this point is what is going to happen with Microsoft Server 2008. It's gotten very good reviews, and people are going to move to it with alacrity -- because it offers significant improvement over the existing product.

Of course, Microsoft expects that eventually people will upgrade to Vista, if for no other reason than new computers will come with it pre-installed. But will they?

With the rise of virtualization, I can certainly see companies choosing to run virtual instances of XP well past the "official" XP availability date. They'll strip off Vista, install a hypervisor, drop an XP instance on top, and go on their merry way. Even worse, from Microsoft's point of view, is the alternative: taking this migration as an opportunity to rethink commitment to Windows and consider moving to Apple or Linux (both of which, by the way, provide a very good virtualization solution to extend the use of XP).

The key, in my view, will be what software providers do regarding Vista. Will they migrate to Vista-only releases, or continue to release on XP as well? If software vendors stop supporting XP, companies will have to move to Vista. If, on the other hand, they continue supporting XP (and why wouldn't they if it continues to be a viable market?), the impetus to move to Vista is dimished.

The bottom line is that people (and companies) make technology decisions based on solving their technical issues. Shouting louder won't make them ignore their real-world experience.

Latest User Comments
There are no comments yet. Be the first to add one!

References

More about Linux, Killer, Apple, Microsoft

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Enter the fully qualified URL, eg. http://www.example.com/
Users posting comments agree to the CIO comments policy.
Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
Newsletters
Sign up for our CIO newsletters!
Syndicate content

URL
www.kyoceramita.com.au

Call us on
Australia: 1800 339 003
New Zealand: 0508 596 2732

Email us
marketing@kyoceramita.com.au

Did you realise that the cost or running a laser printer over its lifetime is likely to exceed the original purchase price by several times? To compare your current printer's running costwith a Kyocera printer, select the TCO Calculator

Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
Kyocera Saves... Try our Saving Estimator now
Calculate Now

Testimonials

 

Wondering how to improve your business with UC on an IP Network?

Join Computerworld's Live Webinar where we will address the move many companies are making towards IP based voice services (SIP trunking, VoIP) and look at how they are using a single connection for data and voice rather than separate lines. Learn about the latest in IP networks and how it can help your organisation.

Wednesday 25th November 2009, Time 10.30 am EST (Sydney, Australia) Screening at your desk

Register now

  • +

    CA brings SOA security to open source JBoss 09 February, 2010 10:08:00

    More commercial options for widely-used app server
    CA has announced its SiteMinder and SOA Security Manager products are now available for the open source JBoss middleware platform.
  • +

    Indian pleads guilty in overseas stock hacking scheme 08 February, 2010 07:50:00

    The group of hackers compromised brokerage accounts, then pumped up the prices of stocks
    An Indian national pleaded guilty Friday to conspiracy and aggravated identity-theft charges related to an international fraud scheme to hack into online brokerage accounts in the U.S. and use them to manipulate stock prices, the U.S. Department of Justice said.
  • +

    E-mail scam steals €3 million in carbon credits 05 February, 2010 06:47:00

    The phishing scheme resulted in losses of up to €3 million from companies
    A clever phishing scheme launched last week may have stolen more than €3 million (US$4.1 million) worth of carbon emission permits from companies.
  • +

    Windows 7 Tips: Best Security Features 04 February, 2010 04:52:00

    IT can specify which applications can run on employees' desktops
    For both enterprises and consumers, one of the big draws of Windows 7 has been its tighter security features.
  • +

    Twitter forces password reset to protect some accounts 04 February, 2010 05:48:00

    The company has discovered that log-in information has been stolen in compromised torrent file-sharing sites
    Twitter required some users to reset their passwords on Tuesday after discovering that their log-in information may have been harvested via security-compromised torrent Web sites, the company said.

Upcoming Industry Events
  • No upcoming events available
Whitepaper

The Pathways ICT Leadership Development Program | Turning today’s ICT professionals into tomorrow’s business leaders

Pathways is a self managed, self paced 12-month program based around the Executive Core Competencies; it allows you to strengthen both your team and your organisation. Learn how key staff can develop their business acumen and management skills now...

CIO Industry Insight Podcast #6: Brenton Smith, Managing Director, CA (ANZ)
Listen to the latest edition of CIO Live which is now available for download.
Listen to the podcast
Sign up to the CIO Live email
Whitepaper
Securing People and Information: How to Protect Against Today’s Web-based Threats

This white paper explores the benefits of an Application Delivery Network, highlighting the ability to protect your users and applications and still deliver outstanding application performance with confidence, consistency and cost-effectiveness across your distributed network.

Read Whitepaper

Brought to you by