CIO
How to Manage Project Risks, Part 5: Leading Indicators of Failure
Too many Sponsors and governance committees rely just on standard project reporting to gauge the status of their project. This is too risky.
Jed Simms  30 October, 2007 11:31:34

The Project Sponsor was most surprised when his project was found to be a 'disaster'. His monthly reports had shown a predominantly 'green' status with some 'ambers'. Basically, his project manager had been lying to him, refusing to allow any items in the monthly report to be rated 'red'.

But the writing was on the wall. If he had paid anything other than cursory attention to his project he would have seen it was 'off the rails'.

  • The technical and change project managers were at loggerheads and had not got on from day one, actively subverting each other's efforts.

  • The project staff were disillusioned with the fact that they could see management was being misled by the project reporting

  • The systems implementer was ready to walk away from the project

  • The business staff had lost complete faith in the project as none of their questions got sensible answers. And so on.

A quick walk down the corridor to where the project team was or into some of the impacted business areas and the Sponsor would have learned very quickly that his project was not as it seemed.

Too many Sponsors and governance committees rely just on standard project reporting to gauge the status of their project. This is too risky.

Project reporting only reports on progress and, usually, immediate issues and risks. The problem is less with what the project reports cover than with what they don't report at all. This is not a case of 'hiding' things or misleading the governance team, but that this is not what project reporting is intended to report.

When I am Sponsor of a project, I want to monitor what is going on (through reporting) but I also want to monitor the leading indicators of failure. This is part of making sure my project succeeds. Just saying, as in the example above, "I didn't know" is of no use when the evidence was clear if only you had looked.

Some leading indicators of failure that all project parties - project and governance teams - should periodically monitor include:

  • Progressive scope change. Is this the project we started out with? Some changes to scope may be necessary, but it is not unusual for the project to gradually veer off in a very different direction to that originally envisaged.

    Every quarter, you need to go back to the original scope and compare it to the current agreed scope - are we still delivering the same project?

  • Progressive staff change. As a project progresses, especially longer projects, people will leave. Some of this is planned but other departures are not. Each person leaving takes with them knowledge of the project, the rationale for decisions and other vital items of information. Every staff change therefore represents significant knowledge loss. Areas of the project can be put at risk, decisions may be revisited as no one knows why the original decision was made, and so on - all extra time and cost with no increased value.

    Each quarter you should look at the team, what is the turnover rate (vis-a-vis the planned rate). What critical resources have left? How many of the project leadership team that started the project is still here? Are there signs of 'rats deserting a sinking ship'?

  • Cash burn rate. Firstly do you know your weekly/monthly cash burn rate? If not, you should find out fast. This tells you quickly the financial impact of potential delays and overruns. While the financial budget may look satisfactory, the alternative measure is the actual cash burn vis-a-vis the planned burn. Under spending is as much a leading indicator that something is wrong as over spending. Changes in cash burn rate can be fully explainable and acceptable. Alternatively, they can be a leading indicator of failure.

Full risk management requires that all of the leading indicators are known, monitored and acted on when necessary.

Click here for the first in this series How to Manage Project Risks

Or to read Jed's previous column, How to Manage Project Risks, Part 4: Corporate Risks click here

Jed Simms is CIO magazine's weekly project management columnist. Simms, founder of projects and benefits delivery research firm Capability Management, is also the developer of specialized project management and project governance Web site www.project-sponsor.com

Comments

Post new comment

Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Enter the fully qualified URL, eg. http://www.example.com/
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Syndicate content

HP Data Center Transformation solutions offer practical ways to overcome the energy and capacity limitations, operational vulnerabilities and technology constraints that can plague your data center. Choosing from a portfolio of solutions matched to your business needs, we can help you transform your data center into a business-driven, process-smart and future-ready asset.

Latest on Data Centre

  • +

    Inside Internode's data centre 05 June, 2009 14:39:00

    Computerworld gets an exclusive behind the scenes look inside Internode's Adelaide data centre with network guru Mark Newton
    Computerworld gets an exclusive behind the scenes look inside Internode's Adelaide data centre with network guru Mark Newton
  • +

    HP uses outside air, big fans, 12-foot raised floor to cool servers 03 June, 2009 07:44:00

    It's also cutting data center power use by painting server racks white
    Just off the North Sea coast in the United Kingdom, Hewlett-Packard Co.'s EDS unit has built a data center that largely relies on cold sea air to keep servers chilled and -- by doing so -- cut the center's cooling power needs in half.
  • +

    HP targets the cloud with new hardware 12 June, 2009 08:27:00

    HP offers complete cloud computing package for businesses
    HP has designed a new portfolio of hardware, software, and services, aimed at reducing costs and saving resource, particularly for businesses involved in Web 2.0, cloud and high-performance computing.
  • +

    Defence to spend $700m on ICT reform 05 June, 2009 11:13:00

    Strategic Reform Program report reveals only half of defence IT budget visible to CIO
    Less than half of the annual $1.2 billion spent by Defence on its ICT is visible to its chief information officer, Greg Farr, a new report has revealed.
  • +

    Inside Telstra's Virtualisation Strategy 11 May, 2009 14:12:00

    Need to cut infrastructure costs driving the strategy
    Telstra is increasingly turning to virtualisation as its core strategy to both manage the rising costs of, and growth in, its data centres, according the company’s CIO, John McInerney.
  • +

    Defence to Initiate ICT Reform Program, Expand CIO Role 05 May, 2009 11:56:00

    ERP rollout, data centre consolidation, single architecture all on the cards, according to the Department of Defence’s strategic policy white paper
    The Defence department has signaled a raft of changes to its approach to information technology under a new ICT reform program.

Free Resource Library

Data Centre Assessments

The First step to Optimising

Speeding business innovation

Removing barriers to growth, increasing agility and driving out costs

Assessments: Ammunition for Facts-Based Decision Making
by Richard L. Sawyer, Senior Principal, HP Critical Facilities Services
Download Podcast Download Transcript
 

CIO Summit The New World Order Opportunities and Challenges for CIOs

23rd July 2009
The Westin Sydney


A content-rich networking event where CIOs and senior executives collaborate on business and technology issues ranging from the impact of the economic downturn to the most pressing trends affecting IT in the enterprise.

Register Now

  • +

    New scam email uses Australian Federal Police to gain victims' trust 03 July, 2009 10:49:00

    Fake offers of free AFP monitoring service to stop "cybernetic attacks"
    Cyber criminals have changed tack in their ongoing scam campaign against banks, moving to the use of government agencies to gain the trust of unsuspecting email recipients.
  • +

    AFP hits $6 million identity fraud syndicate 03 July, 2009 08:25:00

    $500,000 of goods per week purchased with fake credit cards
    The Australian Federal Police (AFP) claims to have struck a major blow to a multi-million identity fraud syndicate.
  • +

    5 steps to secure a new PC 30 June, 2009 00:19:00

    Just unwrapped a brand-new PC? Security pros share their secrets for making your system Internet-safe.
    A common misconception is that a shiny new computer is more or less secure because it hasn't yet been exposed to the Internet's sinister underbelly. But the truth is, these machines come out of the box needing scores of patches, some basic security software downloads and the disabling or replacing of items security pros don't typically trust.
  • +

    Facebook simplifies privacy settings, calls them too complex 02 July, 2009 05:48:00

    The social-networking site is also getting ready to let members share content with anyone on the Internet
    Facebook will simplify the way in which it offers privacy options to its users, as it gets ready to give its members for the first time the option to make the content they post on their profiles available to anyone on the Internet.
  • +

    DR a growing concern for A/NZ CIOs: Symantec 02 July, 2009 09:16:00

    Mission critical apps and cost of down-time major drivers
    CIOs in Australia and New Zealand are increasingly getting involved in the disaster recovery planning of their organisations, according to a new survey from Symantec.
Upcoming Industry Events
  • CIO SummitNSW - Sydney | 23/07/2009 | Hosted by CIO Magazine, IDC & the CIO Executive Council
Whitepaper

An Apple For Your Enterprise?

Whether it's a MacBook Pro or an iPhone, Apple is finding its way into the business world. Desktop Macs are moving into every department and data centers are rolling out Apple storage. They're everywhere. Are you ready?


CIO Industry Insight Podcast #4: Kerry Stratton, Managing Director of Healthcare, InterSystems
Listen to the latest edition of CIO Live which is now available for download.
Listen to the podcast
Sign up to the CIO Live email