Critical.
Authoritative.
Strategic.
Subscribe to CIO Magazine »

Blog: IBM Tries to Patent... Patent Licensing

Ok, so it's a little off-topic. But we've talked about IBM's wacky patents before, and this one is just too good not to note.

It's not a new application (the initial filing date on this is April, 2006 with an ammendment dated April, 2007). Just another overly bold Big Blue patent attempt brought to light by a growing audience of people who have grown tired of overly bold Big Blue patent attempts. It hit the U.S. Patent Office web site last week and Theodp, part-time hunter of ridiculous patents, had it up on Slashdot by Saturday.

It's officially called a "system and method for extracting value from a portfolio of assets." An Associated Press story describes it well: "Specifically, IBM -- which collects more than US$1 billion in patent royalties every year -- describes a new process for licensing patents. Instead of smaller companies licensing technologies from patent holders like IBM in a plodding, one-by-one manner, IBM envisions a more dynamic system with 'floating privileges,' in which patents could be licensed quickly, as needed." In other words, mass licensing. Theodp uses a little more hyperbole, calling the system a Sopranos-esque protection racket: "an extortion scheme whereby a powerful non-governmental organization coerces businesses to pay protection money which allegedly serves to purchase the organization's 'protection' services against various external threats."

Maybe that's going a little far. But however you describe it, this latest patent doesn't exactly line up with the new "business method-free" patent mindset IBM claimed to espouse when Big Blue withdrew its controversial patent on a process for offshoring work: "IBM adopted a new policy a year ago to sharply reduce business method patent filings and instead stress significant technical content in its patents." (For more, see Power to the People: IBM Withdraws Offshoring Patent.) An IP attorney quoted in the AP article says that this latest application most definitely falls in the business method category.

Will IBM back down on this one? I tend to think not. But I've been wrong before.

Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

More about: Big Blue, Billion, IBM

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Users posting comments agree to the CIO comments policy.
Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
Related Whitepapers
Latest Stories
Community Comments
Latest Blog Posts
Whitepapers
  • The State of Privacy & Data Security Compliance
    With the plethora of new privacy and data security regulations, we believe it is time to ask whether regulations help or hinder an organization’s ability not only to protect sensitive and confidential information assets, but to be competitive in the global marketplace. Further, how difficult is it to be in compliance, who is the typical person or functional leader accountable for compliance? What is the value to the organization? Finally, what differences (if any) exist in security practices between compliant and non-compliant organizations?
    Learn more »
  • Shedding Light on Backup and Availability Challenges in Virtual Environments
    This IDG white paper explores specific backup and availability challenges organisations must surmount as they move to virtualise their business-critical applications. It then shows how attaining proper service levels for these applications requires a high degree of visibility into the VMware virtual environment.
    Learn more »
  • Case Study: Svenska Kraftnät safeguards web and ensures communication security with Clearswift
    Energy producers from surrounding countries load power onto the Swedish National Grid’s network, with energy suppliers then paying the Swedish National Grid to load onto their grids for them to sell-on to customers. Using Clearswift’s Email Appliance, and MIMEsweeper for SMTP means that the organisation has safe and resilient email helping them to meet their goal of providing a safe, robust, cost-effective and environmentally sound energy transmission system.
    Learn more »
All whitepapers
rhs_login_lockGet exclusive access to Invitation only events CIO, reports & analysis.
Recent comments