Critical.
Authoritative.
Strategic.
Subscribe to CIO Magazine »

What Is the Moral Responsibility of a Business Leader?

Business leaders cannot afford to overlook the ethical challenges posed by technological advances, as even a single misstep can be enough to undo a reputation

Amid the furore following this disclosure of Whole Foods Market Chairman and CEO Mackey's secret online alias, it is vital that we not lose sight of the critical issues it raises about ethics and leadership in a rapidly evolving business world
There is no question that the current climate has prompted many more companies to tackle ethics issues. Many are making a set of moral values a part of their corporate cultures. And some forward-looking companies are providing ethics training to managers and workers.

While company-wide ethics awareness is a wonderful thing, the recent information about the online persona assumed by Whole Foods CEO John Mackey reminds us that the moral centre of every company lies within its leaders. Those leaders are and should be held to higher standards of ethics and morality — because they are leaders. If, as in the case of Mackey, they are running companies designed around a social responsibility premise, the standards are, and should be, that much higher. The Mackey incident is more about the Achilles' heel of a standard bearer than it is about illegality or immorality.

The Mackey Incident

Whole Foods Market Chairman and CEO Mackey spent years earning a positive reputation as a corporate leader not afraid to take a stand on ethics issues. Before other companies figured out that it pays to be environmentally friendly, Whole Foods led by setting standards for humane animal treatment. In 2006 Mackey took the bold step of reducing his own annual salary to one dollar, pledging money instead for an emergency fund for his staff. Not shy about expressing his views, Mackey challenged leading thinkers, like Nobel prize-winner Milton Friedman, on business ethics issues. Like many leaders, Mackey seemed to relish the public spotlight.

But on July 20, Mackey got more publicity than he bargained for. The Wall Street Journal reported that Mackey had long used the pseudonym "Rahodeb" to make postings in Yahoo Finance forums that flattered his own company and levelled criticisms against the competition. Serious financial and possibly legal repercussions continue to unfold from this incident, and the final consequences may not be known for some time. Amid the furore following this disclosure of Mackey's secret online alias, it is vital that we not lose sight of the critical issues it raises about ethics and leadership in a rapidly evolving business world.

Implications for Leadership and Ethics

By now "business ethics" is an established part of doing business, not just in the United States, but also increasingly around the world. Jokes like "business ethics is an oxymoron" have long since worn thin, as society has come not merely to expect, but to demand, that business conduct itself according to basic rules of ethics and integrity. Business ethics, as an academic topic as well as a growing body of real-world practices, is not a new fad, but is something that has developed since publicized price-fixing and other corporate scandals in the late 1960s and 1970s. The most recent major business scandals, such as Enron, actually served to reinforce widespread perception that "business as usual" can no longer attend only to the financial bottom line.

Join the CIO Australia group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

More about: ACT, Boss, Enron, IT Matters, Leader, Leader Computers, Persona, Strategic Communications, Wall Street, Whole Foods Market, Yahoo

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Users posting comments agree to the CIO comments policy.
Login or register to link comments to your user profile, or you may also post a comment without being logged in.
Related Whitepapers
Latest Stories
Community Comments
Latest Blog Posts
Whitepapers
  • Oracle IT Modernization Series Modernization: The Path to SOA
    More and more organizations are looking to service-oriented architecture (SOA) as the basis of their future computer architecture. Recognizing that legacy application design and implementation approaches have led to applications that are costly to operate and maintain, hard to change, and rely on a dwindling set of skills, organizations are hoping that SOA provides a key component of the answer to these problems. Read on.
    Learn more »
  • Case Study: Understand How Edith Cowan University has Regained Control of their Storage Environment
    Storage infrastructures continue to grow at alarming rates - up to 60% or more, annually. Like many organisations, Edith Cowan University was facing such rapid data growth, with its storage system capacity projected to double each year. Using IBM Tivoli storage solutions, the university has been able to reduce the number of physical disks required and make better use of their existing storage capacity, helping them to make more efficient use of the space in their data centre and reduce their spend on power and cooling. They now make space-efficient snapshots for failover and are able to recover systems in hours instead of days.
    Learn more »
  • IBM agility@scale™: Become as Agile as You Can Be
    Agile software development is an evolutionary, highly collaborative, quality focused approach to software development where potentially shippable working software is produced on a regular basis. Agile software development processes include Scrum, Extreme programming (XP), Disciplined Agile Delivery (DAD) and Agile Modeling (AM), to name a few. Although agile approaches are often equated to the development of Web-based applications, in reality they’re also being applied to mobile applications, fat-client applications, business intelligence (BI) systems and even mainframe applications. They’re being applied by a range of organizations, including but not limited to e-commerce companies, financial companies, manufacturers, retailers and government agencies.
    Learn more »
All whitepapers
rhs_login_lockGet exclusive access to Invitation only events CIO, reports & analysis.

HP and IDG news, product videos and resources